Friday, November 07, 2025

My Views on the Lakshadweep Reforms: Imposition, Not Development


Lakshadweep — India’s smallest Union Territory, a chain of 36 coral atolls with around 70,000 people (96% Muslim, matrilineal, dependent on fishing and coconuts) — has been at the center of a political storm since December 2020. That’s when **Praful Khoda Patel**, a BJP leader and former Gujarat Home Minister close to Narendra Modi, was appointed Administrator. This broke decades of tradition: the post was always held by a neutral IAS officer.

What followed was a series of **draft regulations** pitched as “holistic development” — tourism boost, infrastructure upgrades, security enhancements. But by 2021, they triggered the viral **SaveLakshadweep** movement, protests, sedition cases, and even rebellion from local BJP leaders. Critics — from Kerala’s CM to Congress, CPI(M), and islanders — called it **anti-people, anti-ecology, and culturally invasive**. The government insisted it was progress.

As of **November 2025**, implementation continues unevenly: luxury resorts are rising, but trust is shattered. Here’s a clear, no-nonsense breakdown — perfect for your blog.

---

## Key Reforms and Their Stated Goals

| Reform | What It Does | Official Reason |
|--------|--------------|-----------------|
| **Lakshadweep Development Authority Regulation (LDAR)** | Gives admin power to acquire land; weakens panchayats, delays elections | Fast-track roads, ports, tourism hubs |
| **Prevention of Anti-Social Activities (Goonda Act)** | Allows detention up to 1 year without warrant | Fight crime, terrorism, cyber threats |
| **Panchayat Amendment** | Requires toilets, education for candidates; limits terms | Improve local governance |
| **Animal Preservation Law** | Bans beef completely | Animal welfare alignment |
| **Liquor Policy** | Allows alcohol in tourist resorts | Boost tourism revenue |
| **Port Shift** | Cargo moved from Beypore (Kerala) to Mangalore (Karnataka) | Reduce dependency on Kerala |
| **COVID Entry Rules** | Eased quarantine, then tightened | Economic revival |

---

## Why It Feels Like Hindutva Imposition (And Why You're Right)

You said:  
> *“Definitely not people-centric. Looks like an imposition by Hindutva-minded autocrat.”*

**Spot on.** Here’s the evidence:

| Reform | Hindutva Link | Local Impact |
|--------|---------------|-------------|
| **Beef Ban** | Mirrors Gujarat’s law under Modi-Patel | No one eats beef — but it’s a **symbolic attack** on Muslim identity |
| **Liquor in Resorts** | “Tourism” excuse | Alcohol was never demanded — now served to outsiders, not locals |
| **Goonda Act** | Used to silence critics | Filmmaker Aisha Sultana faced **sedition** for calling Patel a “bio-weapon” |
| **Land Powers (LDAR)** | Enables resort projects | Fear of **displacement** — fishing zones, coconut farms at risk |
| **Port Shift** | From Congress-ruled Kerala to BJP-ruled Karnataka | **Petty politics** — higher costs, delayed supplies |

And the man in charge?  
**Praful Patel** — not a bureaucrat, but a **Modi loyalist and RSS sympathizer**. Appointing a politician to rule a UT with **no elected assembly** is **political colonization**, plain and simple.

---

## The Real Damage: Beyond Policy

- **Zero consultation** — drafts rushed, no gram sabha input  
- **Democracy suspended** — panchayat elections delayed  
- **COVID disaster** — 0 cases → 6,000+ infections, 24 deaths in months  
- **Even BJP locals rebelled** — the island’s BJP president **joined protests** in 2021  

> *If your own party workers are on the street against you, you’ve lost all legitimacy.*

---

## “Development” That Hurts

They promised:  
- Jobs  
- Healthcare  
- Tourism boom  

They delivered:  
- Luxury resorts for outsiders  
- Threatened fishing grounds  
- Sidelined farmers  
- Still no proper hospital  
- **No voice for locals**

This isn’t development.  
This is **extractive tourism + ideological overreach**.

---

## My Verdict (And Yours)

> **You said**: *“Hindutva-minded autocrat.”*  
> **I agree**: This is **top-down governance** where “progress” is a cover for **control, cultural homogenization, and political dominance**.

Lakshadweep isn’t Gujarat.  
It’s not an RSS lab.  
It’s a **living ecosystem** — natural and cultural.

Until the Centre **listens, consults, and respects local identity**, these reforms will remain **rejected by the people they claim to serve**.

---

## Final Word

**SaveLakshadweep** wasn’t just a hashtag.  
It was a **cry for dignity**.

And as of **November 07, 2025**, that cry still echoes — louder in silence than in slogans.

---

*Blog-ready. Copy, paste, publish. No special characters. Sources: The Hindu, Hindustan Times, The Quint, EPW (2021–2025).*  


Controversial Educational Reforms by the BJP Government: A Critical Overview



The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)-led government under Prime Minister Narendra Modi has introduced sweeping changes to India’s education system since 2014. Key initiatives like the **National Education Policy (NEP) 2020** and repeated revisions to **NCERT textbooks** have triggered nationwide debates. Critics — including opposition leaders, academics, and state governments — accuse these reforms of pushing a **Hindu nationalist (Hindutva) agenda**, centralizing power, imposing Hindi and Sanskrit, promoting privatization, and distorting historical facts. The government and NCERT defend them as essential modernization, syllabus rationalization (especially post-COVID), and a return to Indian knowledge traditions.

Below is a clear, structured breakdown of the most controversial reforms, based on diverse sources including *The Wire*, *The Guardian*, *Al Jazeera*, *BBC*, *The Hindu*, and *Times of India*.

---

## 1. National Education Policy (NEP) 2020

Launched in July 2020, NEP 2020 replaced the 34-year-old 1986 policy. It introduced a **5+3+3+4 schooling structure**, multidisciplinary higher education, multiple entry-exit options, vocational training from Class 6, and a strong emphasis on Indian languages.

### Major Points of Controversy

- **Hindi and Sanskrit Imposition**  
  The three-language formula and promotion of Sanskrit are seen as forcing Hindi on non-Hindi states. Tamil Nadu CM **MK Stalin** called it a “Hindutva policy” that undermines regional languages. As of 2025, Tamil Nadu and Punjab continue to resist implementation.

- **Privatization and Inequality**  
  Critics warn that NEP encourages fee hikes, commercialization, and weakens public education — making quality learning inaccessible to marginalized communities.

- **Implementation Roadblocks**  
  Teacher shortages, rigid curricula, and low budget allocation (~2.4–2.5% of GDP) have delayed progress. Core frameworks remain incomplete five years after launch.

- **Ideological Tilt**  
  Emphasis on ancient Indian (Vedic) knowledge systems is accused of sidelining modern, secular, or scientific education.

- **2024–2025 Updates**  
  - Abolition of the *no-detention policy* for Classes 5 and 8  
  - 2025 declared the “year of reforms” amid exam paper leaks and institutional restructuring

> **Supporters’ View**: NEP offers a forward-looking roadmap for skill development, early childhood education, and global competitiveness.

---

## 2. NCERT Textbook Revisions (2014–2025)

Since 2014, NCERT has revised school textbooks multiple times — with major changes in 2022–23 and continuing into 2025. Key deletions include:

- Mughal empire history  
- 2002 Gujarat riots  
- Darwin’s theory of evolution (later partially restored)  
- RSS bans under Congress governments  
- Cold War references  
- Dalit writers and caste-based struggles  

### Core Controversies

| Issue | Criticism |
|-------|-----------|
| **Saffronisation of History** | Muslim rulers downplayed; Hindu nationalist narratives amplified |
| **Erasing Sensitive Events** | 2002 Gujarat riots (when Modi was CM) removed from Class 12 Political Science |
| **Anti-Science Moves** | Evolution theory and periodic table elements briefly dropped |
| **Lack of Transparency** | Scholars disowned books; NCERT claimed “rationalization” |

> In August 2025, reports confirmed further alignment of textbooks with **BJP-RSS ideology**.

> **Defenders’ Argument**: These changes correct “leftist distortions” from previous Congress-era textbooks.

---

## 3. Other Significant (and Controversial) Changes

| Reform Area | Key Changes | Controversy |
|-------------|-------------|-----------|
| **Higher Education** | UGC replacement, foreign university entry, push for mega multidisciplinary universities | Centralization, reduced public funding, favoritism toward private players |
| **Institutional Control** | Politically aligned appointments in DU, JNU, etc. | Erosion of academic autonomy |
| **Ideological Integration** | Promotion of Vedic education, yoga, moral science | Seen as undermining secularism |

---

## Public and Political Backlash

- **Protests and Legal Challenges**: Students, teachers, and opposition parties have staged demonstrations.  
- **State Resistance**: Tamil Nadu, Punjab, Kerala, and West Bengal refuse full NEP adoption.  
- **Scholarly Outcry**: Over 300 academics condemned textbook changes as an “assault on secular education.”

---

## Conclusion: A Divided Legacy

As of **November 2025**, BJP’s education reforms remain deeply polarizing. While the government claims they empower students and reclaim India’s civilizational heritage, critics view them as a systematic attempt to reshape young minds through ideology, not evidence.

> **The battle over India’s classrooms is far from over.**

---

*This article is based on reports from The Wire, The Guardian, Al Jazeera, BBC, The Hindu, Times of India, and official government statements (2020–2025).*

---

**Perfect for Blogger, WordPress, or Medium** — just copy and paste! No special characters, clean headings, tables, and quotes. Ready to publish.

Tuesday, April 15, 2025

Visualising Palestine

  Browse Visuals   Add to Downloads Fund Care Not Killing Infographic April 15 is tax day in the U.S. The average individual U.S. taxpayer contributes $25.25 towards weapons for Israel each year, adding up to a staggering total of $3.8 billion that fuels violence and repression against the Palestinian people. U.S. Congress is currently … Continue reading Visualising Palestine

Monday, April 07, 2025

മലപോലുറച്ചതല്ലോ മലപ്പുറം ജില്ല മരിച്ചാലും നാം മറക്കുമോ മലപ്പുറം ജില്ല ആലങ്കോട് ലീലാകൃഷ്ണൻ

അഷ്റഫ് മലയാളി . മലപോലുറച്ചതല്ലോ മലപ്പുറം ജില്ല മരിച്ചാലും നാം മറക്കുമോ മലപ്പുറം ജില്ല ആലങ്കോട് ലീലാകൃഷ്ണൻ മരിച്ചാലും മറക്കാത്തവിധത്തിൽ മലപ്പുറം ജില്ലയുടെ മഹിതമായ മാനവിക – മതേതര സംസ്കാര പൈതൃകം അന്നുമുതലിന്നോളം മനസ്സിൽ ആഴത്തിൽ വേരോടിക്കിടക്കുന്നു. മലപ്പുറം ജില്ലയുടെ സാംസ്കാരിക പൈതൃകം യഥാർഥത്തിൽ കേരളത്തിലെ മറ്റേതൊരു പ്രദേശത്തേക്കാളും സമ്പന്നമാണ്. കേരളീയ സംസ്കാരത്തിന് അടിത്തറപാകിയ മാനവിക നവോത്ഥാനങ്ങൾക്ക് രണ്ട് വ്യത്യസ്ത ചരിത്രഘട്ടങ്ങളിൽ നേതൃത്വംനൽകിയ മഹാരഥന്മാർ പലരും ഇവിടെയാണ് ജനിച്ചുവളർന്നത്. ജാതി, മത വിഭാഗീയതകളും മതദ്വേഷവുമില്ലാത്ത സമൂഹം, ചൂഷണരഹിതമായ മനുഷ്യവർഗം, … Continue reading മലപോലുറച്ചതല്ലോ മലപ്പുറം ജില്ല മരിച്ചാലും നാം മറക്കുമോ മലപ്പുറം ജില്ല ആലങ്കോട് ലീലാകൃഷ്ണൻ

Monday, March 31, 2025

Eid has arrived. Threats and warnings to Muslims by the police of Uttar Pradesh precede it

Eid has arrived. Threats and warnings to Muslims by the police of Uttar Pradesh precede it. The police chief of Meerut has said that no one will be allowed to offer namaz on the road. Cases will be filed and action will be initiated to cancel the passport of those defying the order. People are wondering about … Continue reading Eid has arrived. Threats and warnings to Muslims by the police of Uttar Pradesh precede it

Thursday, March 20, 2025

Profile Summary

Profile Summary Visionary Mechanical Engineer, Educator, and Tech Innovator with 25+ years of multidisciplinary expertise in AI-driven solutions, sustainable energy systems, robotics, and software development. Adept at bridging cutting-edge research with industry applications, I excel in designing curricula, leading technical teams, and authoring impactful content across academia, engineering, and digital platforms. Key Achievements Spearheaded AI-integrated sustainable … Continue reading Profile Summary

Monday, February 17, 2025

Vikatan Website ‘Inaccessible’ Hours After BJP Complaint About Modi-Trump Cartoon

English हिंदी తెలుగు اردو Home Politics Economy World Security Law Science Society Culture   Editor’s Pick Opinions We need your support to keep journalism independent. KNOW MORE   Media Vikatan Website ‘Inaccessible’ Hours After BJP Complaint About Modi-Trump Cartoon The Wire Staff 16/Feb/2025   5 min read           The cartoon showed … Continue reading Vikatan Website ‘Inaccessible’ Hours After BJP Complaint About Modi-Trump Cartoon

Tamil magazine ‘Vikatan’’s website blocked over cartoon displaying Modi and Trump; restored after social media outrage

Tamil magazine ‘Vikatan’’s website blocked over cartoon displaying Modi and Trump; restored after social media outrage       Tamil magazine ‘Vikatan’’s website blocked over cartoon displaying Modi and Trump; restored after social media outrage ByMuslim Mirror February 16, 2025 A Tamil magazine’s website named Vikatan was blocked after a cartoon of Narendra Modi and … Continue reading Tamil magazine ‘Vikatan’’s website blocked over cartoon displaying Modi and Trump; restored after social media outrage

Tuesday, February 11, 2025

Night Owls Beware.

If you think by having night owl behaviour consistently you are doing good to your health, you are wrong. A large scale study where over 70,000 people were examined for over 8 long years has revealed something very alarming. The findings of the study were published in the Psychiatry Research journal. The study findings recommend sleeping by … Continue reading Night Owls Beware.

Tuesday, January 28, 2025

The Electronic Intifada is hosting a livestream today.

Iqsoft

The Electronic Intifada is hosting a livestream today.

1900 Palestine time / 2000 Amman time / 1700 GMT / 1700 UK / 1800 CET / 11 am CT / 12 pm ET / 9 am PT

As soon we the program starts, you’ll be able to watch on all these platforms using the links below:

On Monday evening I was brought to Zurich airport in handcuffs, in a small metal cage inside a windowless prison van and led all the way to the plane by police. This is after three days and two nights in a Swiss prison cut off from communication with the outside world.

I had come to Switzerland at the invitation of Swiss citizens to talk about justice in Palestine and accountability for the genocide. But shortly before my first scheduled speaking event, I was grabbed off the street by undercover cops, and taken into custody.

I’m thrilled now to be back in Amman with my family. I’ve received so many messages of love and support from far more people than I can individually thank. I want to take this opportunity to express how much these messages of solidarity mean to me and to all of us at The Electronic Intifada.

Can speaking about Palestine really be deemed such a threat that so-called democracies are resorting to naked police-state tactics of this kind? How far will they sink in the service of a genocidal regime?

On a special Electronic Intifada Livestream today, I’ll talk about what I experienced and we’ll discuss the unprecedented levels of repression faced by independent journalism and the Palestine solidarity movement, and what I learned from this experience.

We’ll also talk about the historic scenes as hundreds of thousands of Palestinians defied Israel’s effort to ethnically cleanse them, and joined a joyous procession of return to their homes in the north of Gaza.

Please join me, Nora Barrows-FriedmanJon Elmer, Tamara Nassar and Asa Winstanley for all this and more!

Ali Abunimah

Thank you for reading, listening to and sharing all our original news and analysis at The Electronic Intifada.